
One Man Back: Step Up or Not?

Bill Robertie welcomes the opportunity to share his knowledge of backgammon with experienced players and beginners alike.
On his blog, Robertie publishes set and equipment reviews, creates quiz contests and provides free lessons. He would be remiss not to include his Robertie’s Rules! He also educates readers of the Gammon Press blog on the history of the game, offers backgammon instruction and more.
Use the form to search books, blogs, and resources.

Cash game, center cube.

White to play 4-4.
This position was originally Problem 166, where Black had just danced and the question was whether or not White should double. (The answer was borderline double/no double, and easy take.) Some of the responders asked how White should play a subsequent 4-4, and that did seem like an interesting idea for a problem, so here it is.
Cash game, center cube.

Should White double? If White doubles, what should Black do?
By convention, most cash games use several auxiliary rules beyond the basic rules of backgammon, intended both to speed up the games and increase the stakes in an exciting way. The most common cash game rules are these:
The Jacoby Rule: You can’t win a gammon unless the cube has been turned. This rule eliminates long, dull games where one side gets a huge early edge and plays for the gammon while leaving the cube in the middle.
Automatic Doubles: If both sides roll the same number to start the game, the cube starts at 2. This rule doubles the stakes in one game out of six. Since weaker players tend to play more cautiously with bigger cubes, this rule strongly favors the better player.
Cash game, White owns the cube.

White to play 6-3.
Checker play in holding games is generally a pretty simple matter. When you’re holding onto an anchor and you’re way behind in the race, you try to follow three rules:
1) Keep your anchor as long as you can.
2) Run off your anchor when the alternative is breaking your board.
3) Run off the anchor if staying raises your gammon chances a lot.
If you’re familiar with these rules, you’ll be able to handle most normal holding game positions well.
Things get trickier when you have a third checker back. The third checker can generate more potential shots; it can also get you gammoned if Black can point on the checker and you get stuck on the bar a long time. This position shows a typical situation: Should White stay to get more shots, or run to eliminate gammon chances?
Cash game, center cube.

Should White double? If he doubles, should Black take or drop?
In the last post we talked about the importance of cube benchmark positions — positions where one of the cube decisions (either doubling or taking) was perfectly marginal, while the other was completely clear. Learning typical benchmark positions gives us the ability to analyze a wide variety of related positions over the board with unusual accuracy.
This position shows us another type of useful benchmark. We’re currently just four moves into the game. The opening sequence was
White: 5-3, making the 3-point.
Black: 4-3, bringing down two builders.
White: 6-2, hitting.
Black: 6-3, dancing.
With Black on the bar and White clearly having the upper hand, White now contemplates a double. Considering Sylvester’s three criteria for offering an initial double, here’s how White stands:
Race: solid edge for White. His hit and Black’s fan leaves White up 25 pips, 151 to 176.
Threats: small edge for White. He’s threatening to hit Black’s other blot, but White’s weak board means this is really just a threat to gain a little more ground in the race.
Position: Small but solid edge for White. He has a 2-point board, while Black’s board is undeveloped. White’s extra point, however, is just the 3-point, and there’s no prime in the immediate future. White has almost escaped one of his back checkers, another plus.
To summarize, White has a sizeable edge only in the race, while his other edges are small. Rollouts show that this is a small but correct double, which of course means that the take is very clear. White’s problem is simply that a big lead in the race isn’t as significant as one might think if the inner board is weak. The most likely sequences in that case are ones in which Black easily makes a good anchor or exchanges of hits occur; either of these scenarios minimizes White’s racing lead.
If you were at all tempted to drop this position as Black, just remember that the combination of a weak board, few builders, and an anchor for Black almost always guarantees an easy take. That’s the case here.
Once you know the value of this position in a cash game, you can easily make some practical adjustments for tournament play. If White were trailing in a match, this would be an easy double. If White were the better player, it would also be an easy double, since this will be a long game and White should expect to outplay Black in the later maneuvering.
Cash game, center cube.

Should White double? If he doubles, should Black take or drop?
A key idea in understanding the proper use of the doubling cube on a practical level is that of the “benchmark” position. A benchmark cube situation is a position where one of the decisions (doubling or taking) is a toss-up, while the other is completely clear. Properly understanding a benchmark position is very useful since it unlocks the key to many related positions. Just compare your actual position to the benchmark, spot what the relevant differences, and you should be able to make a good cube decision over the board. Better players are aware of hundreds of good benchmarks, so they can make their over-the-board decisions quickly and accurately.
Cash game, center cube.

Should White double? If he doubles, should Black take or drop?
This position shows a pretty interesting middle game position. Both sides have an anchor, and some points scattered around. White, however, is on roll and shooting at a bunch of blots. He has a total of 27 hits: all sixes, all fives, 4-3, 4-1. 3-2, and 3-3. That’s a lot of hits, so he’s naturally thinking about doubling, and Black is probably worrying whether or not he’ll have a take if White ships the cube.
Cash game, center cube.

Cash game, center cube.
Should White double? If he doubles, should Black take or drop?
We’re in the early stages of the game and White is contemplating a double. Some time ago Joe Sylvester developed a rule for evaluating early doubles. Sylvester advocated looking at three aspects of the position:
(1) Positional advantage (board strength, primes)
(2) The race
(3) Threats
A solid lead in two out of three areas usually translates into a good initial double. A lead in all three guarantees a good double and brings the take into question. Let’s look at all three features of the position in light of Sylvester’s Law and see what we get.
(1) Positional advantage. No one really has a priming structure yet. White has one more home board point and one more outfield point, but Black has his 5-point. Slight edge to White.
(2) Race. Huge edge for White, who leads in the pip count, 118 to 152.
(3) Threats. Another big edge for White, who has five crushing doubles (1-1, 2-2, 3-3, 4-4, and 6-6) plus another six rolls that make the 4-point (6-4, 6-2, 4-2). In addition, White can at least hit loose with most of his other numbers.
A big edge in two out of three categories certainly implies White can double. At the same time, Black has a pretty easy take. White only has three really crushing numbers (2-2, 4-4, and 6-6). Everything else gives Black a chance to anchor on his next turn, with a long game in progress. And of course, Black does have his 5-point, which is a big asset in his favor.
Cash game, center cube.

White to play 6-3.
This position shows one of the most commonly misplayed early game situations. White opened with a 43 and made the building play, 13/9 13/10. It’s the most aggressive choice for an opening 43, designed to make a prime quickly and create a complicated position. Black responded with a 44, making his 9-point and electing to make an advanced anchor rather than hit. (Hitting is also very reasonable.) Now White has a 6-3 to play.
Cash game, center cube.

White to play 5-2.
Here we have a position from the tail end of a mutual holding game. These positions typically arise as follows:
> Both sides make an advanced anchor in the opening.
> Both sides bring down some builders from the midpoint and make a few blockading points.
Neither side ever rolls a big double that would allow it to escape the back men safely.
>Both sides slowly dismantle their blocking points and build inner board points behind the opponent’s anchor.
> Crunch time! Both sides start to face tricky decisions about when to leave the anchor.
Cash game, center cube.

White to play 4-1.
Is backgammon a simple game? No, not at all. There’s a lot you have to know, a lot of technique you have to master, a few formulas to memorize. But some elements of backgammon are easy. At bottom, backgammon’s about hitting blots, making points, and winning the race. read more…
Cash game, Center cube.

Should White double? If he does, should Black take, drop, or beaver?
In this position we have an opening blitz with a few little twists we don’t always see in such situations. Let’s quickly review the features of the position and look at which are important and which are not.
Cash game, White owns the cube.

White to play 3-1.
White has a simple choice in this position: hit with 13/9*, or wait and make a point with 15/12 13/12. Last time we looked at some choices between hitting a blot or making a point in the context of early game play. This position occurs much later in the game, but, as it turns out, the very same principles are still useful. Let’s again list the criteria we explained last time, and see how they apply to this position.
Cash game, center cube.

(a) White to play 3-1.
(b) Same position, White to play 3-2.
Here we see a typical sort of early game position where neither side has made much progress yet. Black has played a 5-3 and a 6-3, making the 3-point and running a checker into the outfield. White has rolled a 5-1, balancing his builders and splitting his back men.
Center cube. Money game. White on move.

Should White double? If he doubles, should Black take, drop, or beaver?
White seems to be doing pretty well in this position. He has a 4-point board, while Black as yet has no new home board points made. Black doesn’t have an anchor yet. White can hit on the 4-point with 18 numbers (all 4s, 3-1, 2-2, 1-1, 6-3, and 3-3.) He has a few more numbers to hit on the 1-point, although that’s certainly not his top choice. White leads by a whopping 38 pips in the race. Looks like White’s concrete assets and threats combine to give him a good double. Can Black even take this? Over the board, a lot of players would drop almost instantly.
Before we pass final judgment on this cube, let’s alter the position just a little bit:

Position A: White on roll.
We’ve moved White’s spare on the 3-point back to the 6-point, where it’s active, and we moved the third checker on the 8-point back to the midpoint. White has lost 8 pips in the race, but his checkers are now where they belong and his position is much stronger.
Position A is a strong double for White and a clear pass for Black. (By the way, it’s not remotely close to being too good to double.) Our original position, by contrast, is also a good double but a clear take. White has threats, but he also has a number of bad rolls, and even when he rolls well to start, his checkers aren’t sufficiently well-positioned to follow up.
Now let’s look at the two positions a little more closely. Position A is what I like to call a balanced position. Given the underlying structure, White’s spares are well-placed and effective. Our original position is unbalanced; here White’s spares are in the wrong places. The spare on the 3-point is mostly useless. The extra spare on the 8-point doesn’t do much, and the broken midpoint is costly in both the long and short term.
The difference between balanced and unbalanced positions is visually pretty clear, but the real difference shows up when we examine White’s bad rolls. (The good rolls will play well anyway.) Let’s list White’s worst rolls and see how they play in both the original position and Position A.
6-6: In the original position, this is a disaster; White is forced to play 13/1* 8/2(2), killing two checkers. In Position A, this is a very good roll; White makes the 1-point.
5-5: In the original, this is another awful roll; White switches with 6/1*(2) and plays 13/3, killing a checker. It’s not as bad in Position A, where White plays 6/1* 13/8 13/3.
6-5: In the original, White kills a checker with 13/2. In A, he plays 6/1* 13/7, much better.
6-2: White plays 3/1* 13/7 in the original. In A, he plays 23/15 because he owns the midpoint, rather than having a blot there. Big edge to A.
6-1: In the original, White makes the 7-point, but gives up control of the outfield. In A, he gets to play 23/16 as before. Another big edge for A.
5-3: In the original, he plays 13/8 with either 24/21 or 23/20. In A, he again takes advantage of owning the midpoint by playing 23/15. Huge edge to A.
5-2: Same story. In the original he plays either 13/6 or 13/8 23/21. In A, he gets to play 23/16. Another big edge to A.
5-1: In the original he plays 13/8 23/22. In A he plays the much stronger 6/1* 2/1.
3-2: In the original he gets to play 3/1* 23/20, activating the checker on the 3-point. In A he plays the massively stronger double-hit.
2-1: In the original he plays 3/1* 2/1 as above, activating a bad checker. In A he gets to play 6/4* 23/22, hitting on the more important point.
As this listing shows, the difference between the standard-looking position in A and the inferior position in the original isn’t slight; it’s actually huge. A lot of players look quickly at the original position and actually “see” something more like A. But the exact placement of all the spares matter, and it especially matters in the case of the bad rolls. In tough cube decisions, try to pay at least a glancing impression as to how concrete rolls actually play, rather than get caught up in forming a general sense of the position.