88 Park Avenue, Suite 302 | Arlington, MA 02476 | 781- 641-2091

The premier source for backgammon books, lessons & blog problems.

"Reading every word, slowly studying each diagram and following your analysis was invaluable to strengthening not only my checker play but my understanding of fundamental backgammon."

Break anchor or slot point?

Nov 15, 2026 | Backgammon Problems: Holding Game

Cash game. White to play 4-2.

 

Note: All ‘cash game’ problems assume the Jacoby Rule is in effect. That is, you can’t win a gammon unless the cube has been turned.

White was doing pretty well in this position. Although down a bit in the pip count (11 pips – 149 to 138), he had accumulated a bunch of positional advantages: good anchor, better home board, and no big stacks. He did have one subtle weakness: a lack of spares in the outfield. Then he threw 4-2 (his worst number) and suddenly that weakness wasn’t so subtle anymore. Now he faces a bunch of unappetizing choices. Let’s quickly consider the main options.

Play A: 8/4 8/6. This is the safest play. White keeps his midpoint and his anchor, and doesn’t leave any new blots. On the downside, he loses his 8-point and creates a much uglier position, with a big stack on his 6-point.

Play B: 8/4 6/4. This play is pretty safe, but also messes up White’s front position. White now has two spare checkers on his 4-point, which will be hard to use effectively in the near future. The blot he leaves behind on the 8-point is pretty safe, but the only rolls that hit (6-1 and 5-2) are among Black’s worst numbers otherwise.

Play C: 13/7. This slots the bar, but breaks the midpoint and leaves two blots. On the bright side, Black’s sixes and twos are somewhat duplicated, since they already played well.

Play D: 13/9 6/4. This play also breaks the midpoint, but doesn’t allow Black to hit and escape with a six. However, White loses still more outfield control.

Play E: 6/2 6/4. White keeps the midpoint and slots the 2-point instead. It’s not terrible, but it’s not exciting either. The 2-point isn’t the next point you want to make, and the 4-point isn’t the best spot for a builder.

Play F: 22/16. White keeps his outfield assets and leaves his home board structure as is, at the cost of abandoning his anchor and leaving three easily attacked blots.

That’s six choices, all bad to some degree. Is there a gem amongst the rubble? Let’s go back to first principles and see what we can puzzle out.

The most famous section in Magriel’s classic work Backgammon is Chapter 16: Safe Play versus Bold Play, where he lists a number of criteria for judging risk-taking. A revelation at the time, the chapter remains solid advice to this day. Let’s review his criteria quickly and see just how applicable they are to this position.

Magriel gives the following conditions as signposts for making a “bold” play:

(1) Trailing in the race and/or more men back.

(2) Good anchor.

(3) Strong inner board.

(4) Opponent has weak inner board.

(5) Opponent has blots strewn around.

The more of these conditions apply, the more likely that a bold, risky play is right. The fewer that apply, the more likely that a safe, conservative play is right.

These conditions are all commonsensical. The first two conditions (more men back, good anchor) endure that you can’t get hurt much if you try a risky play and get hit. The last three conditions ensure that a blot-hitting contest is potentially more dangerous for your opponent than for you. Put them all together and it’s reasonable to take a chance.

Now for some good news and bad news. The good news is that in this position, conditions (1) through (4) all apply. We’re behind in the race, we have more men back, we have an anchor, and our inner board is better than Black’s. Clearly, we’re entitled to make a bold play.

Now the bad news: we don’t have a lot of obviously strong, bold plays available. The positions Magriel discussed were mostly positions where one option was to slot a key point, or hit loose on a key point. Here, the only key point available for slotting is the 7-point, and the slotting play, 13/7, looks pretty weak. It gives up the outfield and leaves a double shot, and hitting either blot just helps Black consolidate his racing advantage. Plus, the chance that he misses the double shot and we then make the bar-point is tiny – only about 20%. That’s a pretty small upside for our “bold” play.

We can make Magriel’s criteria work in this position if we reformulate the definition of a bold play a tiny bit. Instead of just looking to slot a key point, let’s say instead that our good standing with the bold play/safe play criteria gives us the freedom to look for a play that (a) doesn’t ruin the good parts of our position and (b) doesn’t make our weaknesses even worse.

The good part of our position is our strong front game, with four points out of five locked down and our builders on the 6-point reasonably well-placed. All the plays that move the 8-point and 6-point checkers simply mess up our position for the near future, so let’s reject everything like 8/4 6/4 or 8/6 8/4.

The weakness of our position is our outfield game. We have ten checkers tied up in our front position, and another three checkers back. That leaves just the two checkers on the midpoint to give us some outfield presence, and that’s why this roll is so hard to play. But with three checkers back, we need some outfield presence very badly, so we’ll reject plays that break the midpoint 

The Solution: Having rejected those two groups of plays, we’re left with a single choice: the odd-looking 22/16. Now anchor-breaking plays aren’t so odd in themselves; we’ve all seen plenty of examples where breaking an anchor is correct. But they’re usually correct when we’re well ahead in the pip count and looking to turn the game into a straight race. Here we’re simply exploiting our advantage in home board points to preserves the other strengths of our position.